Knowledgebase-Councilmember Acting as City Judge, in Absence of Judge


Information Product

Title:Councilmember Acting as City Judge, in Absence of Judge
Summary:City council member who acted as special judge when city judge was unavailable in past, cannot continue to act as special judge after effective date of Municipal Court Reform Act, which has a section prohibiting city officials or employees from holding office as judge.
Original Author:Ashburn, Melissa
Co-Author:
Product Create Date:04/05/2005
Last Reviewed on::06/26/2017
Subject:Courts--Municipal; Courts--Judges
Type:Legal Opinion
Legal Opinion: Councilmember Acting as City Judge, in Absence of Judge public.doc

Reference Documents:

Text of Document: April 5, 2005


Re: Councilmember acting as city judge, in absence of judge


Dear City Attorney,

I apologize for the difficulty you have had in reaching me this past several days. My office hours have been irregular. Based on your message, it is my understanding that the City has a councilmember who has in the past served as city judge when the judge is unavailable. You have asked if this scenario is legal currently, considering the Municipal Court Reform Act of 2004.

The Municipal Court Reform Act of 2004 includes the following provision:

Notwithstanding any provision of the law to the contrary, a judge of a municipal court may not concurrently hold any other office or employment with the municipality. The provisions of this section do not apply to any municipal official or employee who, on the effective date of this act [March 1, 2005] concurrently holds office as judge of the municipal court; provided, however, if such employee or official either discontinues service as a municipal official or employee or discontinues service as judge of the municipal court, then the exemption granted by this sentence no longer applies. T.C.A. ' 16-18-307.

As the councilmember acted as special judge during the judge's unavailability before March 1, 2005, you have asked if the exemption provided in this section of the law would apply, so that the arrangement may continue. In my opinion, the answer is "no," based on the fact that a special judge, or a person selected to serve in the absence of the municipal judge, does not hold the office of judge. The exemption applies to those persons who hold the office of municipal judge, not to persons who temporarily assume the office when the judge is unavailable. It is my opinion that the councilmember may not serve as temporary, or special judge due to the prohibition contained in the first sentence quoted above.


I hope this information is helpful. Thank you for consulting with MTAS.

Sincerely,

Melissa A. Ashburn
Legal Consultant

Please remember that these legal opinions were written based on the facts of a given city at a certain time. The laws referenced in any opinion may have changed or may not be applicable to your city or circumstances.

Always consult with your city attorney or an MTAS consultant before taking any action based on information contained in this database.